Pindear/Compare/Smart Humidifier 512S 5L vs Smart Humidifier 717S 8L with Demineralization Cartridge

Smart Humidifier 512S 5L vs Smart Humidifier 717S 8L with Demineralization Cartridge

Side-by-side on the specs that matter, with category winners and an opinionated take to help you decide.

The VerdictAI-generated · editor-reviewed

The choice is between a compact 5L humidifier and a larger 8L model with a demineralization cartridge.

ASmart Humidifier 512S 5L

Pick the Smart Humidifier 512S 5L if you have a small to medium room and want a simpler, more compact setup.

BSmart Humidifier 717S 8L with Demineralization Cartridge

Pick the Smart Humidifier 717S 8L if you have hard water or a larger space and want less maintenance and longer runtime.

Trade-offs to own
  • The 512S is smaller and lighter but needs more frequent refills.
  • The 717S is bigger and bulkier but runs much longer per fill.
  • The 717S adds a demineralization cartridge to reduce white dust but requires cartridge replacement.

Full specs

Ask about this comparison

Ask anything — we'll answer with Smart Humidifier 512S 5L and Smart Humidifier 717S 8L with Demineralization Cartridge in mind for home use.

Check price
Smart Humidifier 512S 5L
Check price
Smart Humidifier 717S 8L with Demineralization Cartridge

Pindear may earn a commission when you buy through these links. Winners are determined by numeric spec comparisons only; non-numeric features (app quality, ecosystem, real-world feel) are covered in the verdict.

Ask Pindear

Ask me anything about smart hardware